Introduction to Criminal Background Check Errors

A criminal background check is a process used by employers, landlords, and other organizations to assess an individual’s criminal history. These checks are conducted to ensure that a person does not have a history of criminal activity that could pose a risk to others or the organization itself. Criminal background checks can provide crucial insights into an individual’s past, including arrests, convictions, and sometimes even pending charges.

These background checks may be used for various reasons, such as:

• Employment Screening: Employers often conduct criminal background checks as part of their hiring process to ensure the safety and security of the workplace. This helps employers make informed decisions about potential employees, especially for roles requiring trust, such as those involving children, the elderly, or financial responsibilities.
• Housing Applications: Landlords and property management companies may require criminal background checks to determine if potential tenants have a history of criminal activity that could jeopardize the safety of other residents or the property.
• Loan and Financial Applications: Financial institutions may perform background checks when individuals apply for loans or credit to assess their reliability.
• Licensing: Certain industries require individuals to pass criminal background checks before granting professional licenses (e.g., healthcare providers, lawyers, etc.).

Criminal background checks can vary based on jurisdiction and the level of information needed. For example, federal background checks may reveal nationwide criminal records, while state or county checks typically only cover local offenses.

Common Errors Found on Criminal Background Checks

While criminal background checks are an essential tool for evaluating an individual’s history, errors in the information reported can have serious consequences. Some of the most common errors that appear on criminal background checks include:

1. Mistaken Identity: One of the most frequent errors is the misidentification of an individual due to shared names, similar birthdates, or other matching personal details. For instance, a person named “John Smith” with a similar birthdate to someone with a criminal record may have their information wrongly linked to the criminal’s history.
2. Reporting Inaccuracies: In some cases, criminal background checks may include incorrect charges, dates, or court records. For example, an individual might be mistakenly listed as having been convicted of a crime they were acquitted of, or their sentence may be reported inaccurately.
3. Outdated or Sealed Records: Some background checks may incorrectly report outdated or sealed records. A criminal record that was expunged or sealed by the courts may still appear, affecting an individual’s ability to secure employment or housing.
4. Duplicate Records: Errors can also occur if the same person’s record is reported multiple times due to clerical errors, causing confusion or unnecessary concern for those undergoing background checks.
5. Incorrect Address or Contact Information: Sometimes, background checks include errors related to personal details, such as incorrect addresses or misspelled names. These discrepancies may cause delays or complications during the verification process.

Why It’s Crucial to Correct Errors on a Criminal Background Check

The accuracy of criminal background checks is crucial, as inaccuracies can lead to severe consequences. For individuals, errors on a criminal background check can:

• Result in Denied Job Opportunities: A criminal background check that contains errors can lead to job rejections. This is particularly common for positions that require a clean record or have strict hiring criteria. A mistake in the background check could prevent someone from gaining employment and disrupt their livelihood.
• Cause Housing Issues: Inaccurate criminal background checks can prevent individuals from securing rental properties. Landlords often rely on these checks to make decisions about potential tenants, and a false report may lead to denied rental applications or evictions.
• Create Legal Complications: Incorrect information on a criminal background check can also result in legal ramifications for both individuals and organizations. For example, if a company hires someone based on inaccurate information, they could face legal liabilities if the individual causes harm. Similarly, individuals may face legal challenges when attempting to dispute incorrect records.

How Do Errors on Criminal Background Checks Happen?

Errors in criminal background checks can occur at several stages of the process:

1. Human Error: Background check companies may make clerical or typographical errors when inputting data into their systems. For example, misspelling a name or incorrectly entering a date of birth can lead to a mismatch or false report.
2. Data Entry Mistakes: Criminal history data is often pulled from multiple sources, such as court records, police databases, and arrest records. If the information is entered incorrectly at any of these points, it can lead to inaccurate or incomplete reports.
3. Database Discrepancies: Criminal background checks typically rely on large databases containing public records. Sometimes, the data stored in these databases is outdated or incorrect. If someone’s criminal record is expunged or sealed and the database is not updated, it may still show up on a background check.
4. Faulty or Outdated Records: Records may not be updated in real time, especially if they pertain to older cases or jurisdictions with less efficient record-keeping systems. This can result in outdated information showing up on a background check.
5. Identity Theft or Fraud: In some cases, an individual’s criminal history may be incorrectly attributed to another person due to identity theft. If someone uses another person’s identity for criminal activity, it can cause discrepancies on background checks.

Steps to Identify Errors in a Criminal Background Check

Before correcting any errors, it’s essential to identify them. Individuals should follow these steps to review their criminal background check:

1. Request a Copy of Your Criminal Background Check: The first step is to obtain a copy of the criminal background check report. In most cases, individuals can request a free copy of their report, especially if the check is being used for employment purposes.
2. Review the Report Carefully: Once you receive the report, review it thoroughly to check for discrepancies. Pay attention to personal information, such as your name, date of birth, and addresses, as well as any criminal charges or convictions listed.
3. Cross-Check with Your Records: Compare the information on the background check with your own records. If you notice any differences, such as a charge that does not belong to you, this may indicate an error.
4. Look for Outdated or Expunged Records: If you have any criminal records that were sealed or expunged, ensure that they are not listed on the report.
5. Contact the Reporting Agency: If you find any discrepancies, contact the background check company or agency responsible for providing the report. Most agencies will provide you with instructions on how to dispute errors.

How to Dispute Errors on a Criminal Background Check

When errors are identified on a criminal background check, it’s crucial to take the appropriate steps to correct them as quickly as possible. An inaccurate report can have severe consequences for employment, housing, and even legal matters. Below is a step-by-step guide on how to dispute and correct errors on a criminal background check.

1. Contact the Background Check Company or Agency
   The first step is to reach out to the company or agency that conducted the background check. This could be a private background check agency or a government body that oversees criminal records. Most background check agencies allow individuals to dispute errors either by phone, email, or online portal.
2. Review the Error and Gather Proof
   Once you’ve identified the error, you must gather the necessary documents to prove that the information on the background check is incorrect. Common documentation to support your case includes:
   • Court documents showing that the charges were dismissed, expunged, or not applicable.
   • Identification documents, such as a driver’s license or passport, to confirm your identity.
   • Records from the police or jail showing that you were not involved in the crime in question.
3. Submit a Dispute Form
   Most agencies require you to fill out a dispute form. This form will ask for details regarding the error and the supporting documentation. Be as specific as possible when describing the discrepancy to ensure the agency understands what needs to be corrected.
4. Follow Up to Ensure Timely Resolution
   After submitting your dispute, it’s important to follow up with the agency to confirm that they’ve received your documents and are processing the dispute. Keep records of all your communications and responses. The agency is generally required by law to resolve the dispute within a certain period—typically 30 to 45 days.
5. Get a Copy of the Updated Report
   Once the error has been corrected, request a copy of your updated criminal background check to ensure that the changes have been made. Review the report carefully to ensure the accuracy of the corrections.

Legal Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) provides legal protections for individuals when it comes to disputes over inaccuracies in background checks. If you discover an error on your criminal background check, the FCRA gives you the right to dispute the information and requires the reporting agency to investigate and correct any errors.

The FCRA mandates the following protections:

• Right to Dispute: You have the right to dispute any information on your background check that you believe is inaccurate or incomplete. The reporting agency must investigate your dispute, typically within 30 days.
• Right to Access: Under the FCRA, you are entitled to a free copy of your background check if it has been used against you in an adverse decision, such as a job rejection. You can request a copy of your report from the agency that conducted the background check.
• Obligation to Correct Errors: If the agency determines that the information is incorrect, they must correct the error and notify you. They also must notify any parties who received the inaccurate report in the past.
• Right to Sue: If a background check company fails to correct errors or violates the FCRA, you have the right to sue for damages.

Common Challenges in Correcting Errors

While the process for correcting errors on a criminal background check is straightforward, there are several challenges that individuals may face. Here are some of the most common issues:

1. Long Resolution Times: Disputes often take 30 to 45 days to resolve, and the process can be frustrating, especially if the individual needs the background check for time-sensitive purposes, such as a job application or housing agreement.
2. Difficulty Obtaining Documents: Obtaining the correct documentation to prove your claim may be difficult, especially if you have a history of sealed or expunged records, or if the records are from another state or jurisdiction with different requirements.
3. Inconsistent Reporting Across Agencies: Not all agencies use the same sources of information or reporting practices. This inconsistency can lead to discrepancies between different reports, making it more difficult to resolve issues.
4. Non-Cooperative Employers or Agencies: In some cases, employers or agencies may not cooperate in resolving the errors on the background check. This is particularly true if the background check is related to a pending legal matter or an ongoing investigation.

Working with Employers or Agencies to Resolve Errors

In some cases, individuals may find it challenging to resolve errors on their own. If an error on your criminal background check is preventing you from getting a job, housing, or other opportunities, working with employers or government agencies may help expedite the process.

1. Work With Employers: If an error on your criminal background check results in a job rejection, you can ask the employer to reconsider your application once the error is resolved. Employers are generally required to provide you with a copy of the background check report if it was used to make an adverse decision. You can then provide corrected documentation and request that the employer reevaluates their decision based on accurate information.
2. Collaborate with Government Agencies: If the error relates to court records or police reports, contact the agency responsible for maintaining the records. Many jurisdictions have procedures in place for individuals to update or correct errors in criminal records. If necessary, contact the Department of Justice or local government offices for guidance.

Precisehire’s Role in Helping with Background Check Errors

Precisehire offers services that help individuals and businesses ensure that criminal background checks are accurate, reliable, and up-to-date. By leveraging Precisehire’s advanced background check system, both employers and employees can ensure that any discrepancies or inaccuracies are addressed before they affect employment or other opportunities.

Some ways Precisehire can assist include:

• Accurate Background Checks: Precisehire provides thorough background checks that ensure all relevant records are considered and verified. This reduces the likelihood of errors related to mistaken identity or outdated information.
• Expert Assistance in Disputing Errors: Precisehire can assist both employers and candidates in disputing errors found on criminal background checks. By providing access to legal experts and resources, Precisehire helps ensure that any mistakes are resolved efficiently.
• Ongoing Monitoring: Precisehire offers ongoing monitoring services to alert individuals or businesses to any new developments in criminal records, ensuring that background checks remain accurate and up-to-date.

Preventing Future Errors

To prevent errors on future criminal background checks, individuals and businesses can take proactive steps, such as:

1. Regularly Monitor Criminal Background Reports: By periodically checking their own criminal background reports, individuals can catch errors early and dispute them before they affect employment or housing decisions.
2. Keep Personal Records Updated: Ensure that personal information (e.g., name, address, date of birth) is accurate and consistently reported across all relevant databases. This can help prevent issues of mistaken identity.
3. Submit Accurate Information: Always ensure that the information submitted during background checks is correct, and provide all relevant supporting documentation to avoid errors.

---

Data Table: Common Errors Found on Criminal Background Checks

Error Type	Description	Possible Consequences	How to Correct
Mistaken Identity	Criminal record of a person with a similar name or birthdate.	Job or housing denial.	Provide court documents or ID to prove it’s not your record.
Reporting Inaccuracies	Incorrect charges, dates, or court records.	Legal complications, employment issues.	Submit court documents showing acquittals or dismissals.
Outdated or Sealed Records	Old or expunged records still appear on the background check.	Difficulty in securing a job or housing.	Request updated records or proof of expungement.
Duplicate Records	The same offense is reported multiple times due to clerical errors.	Delay in background check processing.	Dispute duplicate entries with supporting documentation.
Incorrect Address/Contact Info	Address or personal details don’t match with official records.	Confusion in verification processes.	Correct personal details with the reporting agency.

Legal Aspects of Criminal Background Check Errors

When errors on a criminal background check are not addressed properly, they can lead to significant legal consequences. Understanding the legal framework surrounding these errors is crucial, as it ensures that individuals know their rights and what actions they can take to rectify the situation.

Relevant Laws and Regulations

Several laws and regulations protect individuals from being negatively impacted by errors in criminal background checks:

1. Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
   The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is the primary law governing how background checks are conducted and how errors must be handled. Under the FCRA:
   • Individuals have the right to dispute inaccurate information on their background checks.
   • Background check agencies must investigate disputes within 30 days.
   • If the dispute results in changes, agencies must notify the individual and any organizations that received the inaccurate report.
   • The FCRA requires companies to ensure the information provided in a background check is accurate and up-to-date.
2. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) Guidelines
   The EEOC provides guidelines on how criminal background checks should be handled in employment decisions. Employers are prohibited from using criminal records as a blanket disqualification tool. Instead, employers must consider the nature of the crime, the time passed since the offense, and its relevance to the position in question. Additionally:
   • Employers are required to notify applicants if a criminal background check was used to make an adverse decision, such as denying a job.
   • Applicants must be given the opportunity to dispute any inaccurate information before a final decision is made.
3. State-Specific Laws
   Various states have their own regulations regarding background checks, particularly when it comes to the use of criminal records in employment or housing decisions. For example, some states have “ban the box” laws, which prohibit employers from asking about criminal history on job applications. Additionally:
   • States like California and New York have laws that provide individuals with specific rights to dispute criminal record inaccuracies.
   • Some jurisdictions have more stringent rules about expunging or sealing criminal records, which can also affect how background checks are conducted.

Legal Implications of Background Check Errors

When errors on a criminal background check are not corrected or acknowledged, both individuals and employers may face legal challenges. For instance:

• Employment Discrimination: If a person is wrongfully disqualified from a job due to an inaccurate criminal background check, it could lead to claims of discrimination. The EEOC mandates that employers consider more than just the existence of a criminal record in hiring decisions.
• Housing Discrimination: If an error on a criminal background check prevents an individual from securing housing, they may have legal recourse under the Fair Housing Act, which protects individuals from discrimination based on their criminal history.
• Legal Liability for Employers: Employers who fail to properly investigate or dispute errors on criminal background checks could face legal action. If an applicant is unjustly rejected due to inaccurate information, the employer may be held liable for damages under the FCRA.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Conclusion

Errors in criminal background checks can significantly impact an individual’s life, preventing access to employment, housing, or other critical opportunities. Understanding how to dispute and correct these errors is essential to ensuring your rights are protected.

In addition to knowing the steps to take when errors occur, understanding the legal protections provided by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and other relevant laws is crucial. These laws empower individuals to challenge inaccurate information and hold agencies accountable for providing faulty background checks.

To ensure that criminal background checks are accurate, both individuals and businesses can turn to Precisehire, a service that offers thorough and reliable background checks. Precisehire not only provides accurate reports but also assists with the correction process, ensuring that discrepancies are resolved promptly.

Staying proactive in monitoring your criminal background check and understanding the rights afforded to you under the FCRA and other laws can prevent issues before they arise. By taking these steps, you can avoid the legal and personal consequences of inaccurate criminal background checks and ensure that your opportunities are not unfairly impacted by errors.